Skip to main content

New Barangay Captain in Loay Bohol Takes Oath

By Angeline Valencia

      Recount victor, Narciso Avelino, recently assumed office as barangay captain of Poblacion Ibabao in the municipality of Loay after the about 10-month course of election case that booted out Ricardo Duco, the declared winner in the October 2007 elections.

      Avelino took his oath before Mayor Rosemarie Lim-Imboy on September 5.

      This was after the Municipal Circuit Trial Court (MCTC) Branch 13 in Loay, covering the Loay-Alburquerque-Baclayon jurisdiction, issued a writ of execution dated September 4, 2008, through Clerk of Court Gertrudes  Romero.

      This was based on the order of MCTC Branch 13 Presiding Judge Alejandro Canda, bearing the same date, that directed the issuance of the writ of execution for the implementation of the court decision.

      Canda explained in his brief order that the decision of MCTC Branch 13 "has attained finality upon the 'order of dismissal of the appeal with finality' dated August 21, 2008" that the Commission on Elections had issued, and the entry of judgment also dated August 21, 2008.

      Avelino, through his counsel, Lawyer Aleck Francis Lim, submitted a manifestation/compliance on September 2 before the MCTC Branch 13 showing that he received on that day, copies of the entry of judgment dated August 21, 2008 and the order from the first division of the Commission on Elections also dated August 21, 2008 denying Duco's urgent manifestation/motion to defer implementation of the order dated July 23, 2008 "for lack of merit". It was to manifest that the Comelec had already dismissed Duco's appeal with finality and that it's already in the Book of Entries of Judgment.

      The entry of judgment, that Director Betty Pizaña of the Electoral Contests Adjudication Department (ECAD) issued, certified that the first division of the Comelec issued an order on April 30, dismissing Duco's instant appeal for failure to file his notice of appeal and failure to pay the appeal fee as prescribed under the Comelec Rules of Procedure within five-day reglementary period; that an order dated May 22, 2008 denied Duco's verified motion for reconsideration for failure to pay the required motion fees; and that the order dated July 23, 2008 called for the issuance of the entry of judgment in the instant case and directed the Judicial Records Division-ECAD of Comelec First Division to remand within three days, the entire records of the case to MCTC Branch 13 for proper disposition.

      Earlier, MCTC Branch 13 issued a decision in January this year finding Avelino as the duly elected barangay captain of Poblacion Ibabao with a total of 325 votes against Duco, who only got a total of 321 votes, based on the recounting done.

      This restrained Duco from assuming as barangay captain of Poblacion Ibabao.

      In January this year, Duco filed an appeal before the Commission on Elections (Comelec) for the reversal of the decision of MCTC Branch 13 that dismissed him after finding irregularity in the counting of votes during the October 2007 polls.

      The court found Avelino actually leading by four votes based on recounting.

      In a seven-page decision, MCTC Branch 13 Acting Judge Jennifer Chavez-Marcos cited that of the 326 votes counted in favor of Duco, five were stray votes. This leaves Duco with only 321 votes, actually.

      On the other hand, Chavez-Marcos considered the four ballots bearing only the official nickname of Avelino, as valid. This added four votes to Avelino, making it 325 instead of just 321 as previously counted.

      The case stemmed from Avelino's instant election case filed on November 8, last year against Duco after four ballots bearing his nickname, Sisoy, were considered invalid during the canvassing in four precincts.

      Avelino then sought for the dismissal of Duco, alleging fraud in the synchronized barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan (SK) elections on October 29, last year.

      Duco denied Avelino's allegations of irregularity in the counting of the ballots for the barangay captain.

      But Avelino called for a recounting of ballots from Precincts 0004A-0004B, 0005A-0005B, 0006A and 0007A-0007B.

      During the pre-trial conference on November 3, last year, it was disputed that Avelino got 321 votes in the four precincts, while Duco got 326 and that Avelino's watcher failed to raise objection on the Neighborhood Rule applied on the seven votes intended for him and the declaration of the three ballots bearing his nickname as invalid.

      The Board of Election Tellers declared seven votes from Precincts 0005A-0005B, 0006A and 0007A-0007B as invalid since Avelino's name was written on the space other than the designated one for barangay captain in the ballot.

      The Board of Election Tellers also declared three votes from the three precincts invalid since only the word, Sisoy (Avelino's official nickname) was written on the space intended for choice of barangay captain in three ballots.

      Revision was conducted from November 29 to December 3, last year from which the chairman of the Revision Committee, Gertrudes Romero, came up with a report dated December 7, 2007.

      Based on the report, the court cited the Rules for the Appreciation of Ballots in section 211 of Article XVII (Counting of Votes) in the Omnibus Election Code which explains that "…the object of the election is to obtain the expression of the voter's will", and that "every ballot shall be presumed valid unless there is clear and good reason to justify its rejection". For the ballot in precinct 0007A-0007B that contained the name S AELINO on the space for barangay captain, the court considered that "it is very close in spelling and similarly sounding" to "Avelino".

      The court cited the rule of "sounding the same or nearly alike" which explains that "if the name as spelled in the ballot, although different from its orthographically correct spelling, sounds practically the same when pronounced according to our method of pronunciation, it is sufficient designation of the individual to whom it refers, and the error of the writer must not be taken into account.

      The court also explained that "the misspelling of a name or lack of skill in writing it, should not be taken as a ground for rejecting the votes apparently intended for a candidate, so long as the intention of the voter appears to be clear". Rule 7 of section 211 of the Omnibus Election Code also states that "a name or surname incorrectly written, which when read, has a sound similar to the name or surname of a candidate when correctly written shall be counted in his favor," the court cited.

      The votes for Avelino that the Board of Election Tellers rejected included those contained in three ballots, two from Precinct 0006A, one from Precinct 0005A-0005B, and one from Precinct 0004A-0004B which all contained the name "Sisoy" on the first line for the position of barangay councilor.

      Citing the neighborhood rule, the court opined "that a vote for a candidate for a position written near the line or space for such position which is left vacant is a valid vote for such candidate".

      On the other hand, Avelino also protested four ballots for Duco, of which three were from Precincts 0006A, 0005A and 0005B which contained words that were unreadable and one from Precinct 0007A-0007B with a name that was neither the real name, nor nickname, nor surname of Duco.

      The court considered them stray votes as far as the position of barangay captain is concerned, since the names on the space for barangay captain in the four ballots were totally unreadable and could not stand for a particular candidate.

Popular posts from this blog

Panglao Bohol International Airport Update

The Department of Transportation and Communication (DOTC) has endorsed Gov. Erico Aumentado's request to frontload the 2010 budget for the Panglao Bohol International Airport to 2009.
  In a letter to Budget and Management Secretary Rolando Andaya, DOTC Secretary Leandro Mendoza favorably endorsed Aumentado's request seeking the frontloading, citing among other reasons, that 2010 is an election year.
  As such, Aumentado had explained, Congress might not be able to approve on time the calendar year 2010 General Appropriations Act (GAA), giving the country no other choice but to operate on a reenacted budget.
  A reenacted budget would jeopardize the airport project, the governor pointed out, because the 2009 budget carries only P307.5 million for the airport. The balance of the amount that President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo earlier approved for DOTC to come up with stands at P690,971,398 for a total allocation needed of P998,471,398.
  The Manila International Airport Authority (MI…

Bohol Tourist Spots - Bohol Attractions

Heading east from Tagbilaran along the south coast takes you first to the coastal fishing town of BOOL , 5km away. Said to be the oldest settlement on the island, it's also the site of the  Blood Compact Site, marked by an attractive bronze sculpture on the seafront. This is the spot where local chieftain Rajah Sikatuna and Miguel Lopez de Legazpi concluded an early round of Philippine–Spanish hostili-ties in 1565 by signing a compact in blood. Every year for one week in July, Boholanos gather in Bool for the  Sandugo  (One Blood)  festival  which, apart from the usual beauty pageants and roast pigs, includes a passionate re-enactment of the blood ceremony.
About 2km east of Bool, BACLAYON  is the site of  Baclayon Church, the oldest stone church in the Philippines. Much of the existing facade was added by the Augustinian Recollects in the nineteenth century, but the rest dates back to 1595 and was declared a national historical landmark in 1995. The church's convent has been t…

Muslims in Bohol Philippines

The Muslim communities scattered all over Bohol stood us one Friday to make an unfavorable position of the hasty agreement defining the so-called ancestral domain of the Bangsamoro people.The ethnic leaders assembled Friday at Camp Dagohoy to witness the blessing and inauguration of the  new police center catering to Muslim issues and concerns. It is called Sala'am Center.It was an opportune time for the Post to get the reaction of the Muslim leaders given the combustible issue of a peace agreement between the government and the Moro Islam Liberation Front (MILF) now catching fire from all segments of Philippine society.The government and the MILF on Tuesday were set to sign a memorandum of agreement on ancestral domain following 10 years of off-and-on negotiations. But the Supreme Court stopped the ceremony after local Mindanao officials protested the inclusion of their areas in an expanded Moro homeland without consultations.Critics said the broad economic and po…